Fred Schulte Asks, "Why Not Extrapolate?"

If you have missed his series of articles in the Center for Public Integrity website, you will want to make his acquaintence with his appearance on an National Public Radio article (see link below).  I received a call from Fred last week and we explored the issue of extrapolation penalties for Medicare Advantage RADV audits.  

http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/06/17/

In short, Fred's contention is that there is "upcoding" of procedure codes for FFS Medicare billing that is subjected to OIG audits and subsequent extrapolation penalites, which should be the same standard applied to diagnostic "upcoding" under Medicare Advantage.  This means that any errors discovered in a RADV audit would be subject to a penalty that is extrapolated across the whole population: chart audit confirmation of diagnostic codes would have zero tolerance for non-validation. 

This view is being voiced now by Senator Grassley and others who are stepping up pressure on CMS to take actions against Medicare Advantage Organizations.  The OIG has set a target amount for recovery of "overpayments" to MAOs based upon this interpretation of "upcoding".  Mr. Schulte's perspective is that "upcoding" on the part of the MAOs is being done to milk the system at the expense of the U.S. Taxpayer.

What is the evidence that "upcoding" is taking place?  First, there is a significantly higher prevalence of diagnoses among Medicare Advantage members than among beneficiaries under Original Medicare.  Second, there was a large percentage of conditions identified in the 2007 RADV audits that failed validation. Putting together these two data points, the conclusion being drawn is that the MAOs are "gaming the system". 

At a minimum, the pressure being created by this publicity is going to turn the thumb screws on CMS to be more transparent about their methodology and approaches to ensuring that the U.S. Taxpayers are not being "gouged" by the MAOs.  Would this cause CMS to be more forthcoming about their findings in contract level RADV audits, as well as their tools and standards?  Perhaps.  Would our industry welcome the disclosure of "bright line" transparency?  We are of mixed opinions about this since ambiguity allows the lattitude that some relish. But it also provides a grey zone that invites abuse by some. 

Get informed. Get involved in RISE and give us your opinions.  We are going to have to work together on moving towards more compliant and more accurate outcomes. 

 


Tags: extrapolation

Log on to Your Rise Account

Forgot your password?
Create an Account

Association Sponsors

Latest Posts

Keep M.E.A.T. on Your List for a Healthy Audit

By Jeanmarie Loria, Advize Health, LLC If you’re reading this article, chances are you already know what HCC Coding is – but we’ll give you a refresher anyway. Hierarchical Condition Category (HCC) and Risk Adjustment Coding is a CMS-mandated payment model. This model works to identify those with chronic and other serious illnesses and prescribes a risk factor score to each patient, taking into consideration their ailments and other demographics. With every payment model comes a specific set of audit and review requirements that must be met to maintain the integrity of the system, and this is where MEAT (Monitor, Evaluate, Assess/Address, Treat) comes in handy. In a face to face visit M.E.A.T. maybe found in the chief complaint, history of present illness, review of systems, physical exam, assessment and/or plan....
Read More

Getting It Right: True North in Healthcare Reform

The movement to repeal and replace "ObamaCare" created so much political noise that clear thinking has been hard to come by. The 2010 legislation that created the marketplace for individuals and small business (the Affordable Care Act or ACA), has almost evolved into a political Rorschach test. The more that politicized options and alternatives to repealing, replacing, or repairing it were discussed, the harder it was to put into focus the original problems the legislation was designed to address. Nevertheless, the rancorous divisions over what needs to happen to fix problems in the individual insurance market remain a distraction from the real issue at hand: the cost of healthcare weighing down the economy and what we need to do to fix it. With all the intense debates swirling around this topic, an impression emerges that “solving the ObamaCare issues” is something that must be accomplished as an isolated matter, discrete and independent of other problems. The heated debates concentrate on the mechanics and tactics required to solve the "uninsured problem", the "under-insured problem", and for some, the federal budget problems created by the subsidies for low-income enrollees in these plans. This single-issue mono-vision obscures a reality that must be addressed. This perspective completely misses the fact that something is going on that is far more corrosive to the wellbeing of all of us as consumers of health care, as taxpayers, and as a nation: something that overshadows the tug ‘o war over ObamaCare. The critical and overlooked issue is that health care expenditures in the U.S are at least twice as expensive as other nations, which consume so much of the national economy...
Read More

Upcoming Conference

 

Qualipalooza: The 2nd Annual RISE Quality Leadership Summit 

This unique event incorporates three conferences presented side-by-side: the Star Ratings Strategic Planning Forum, the HEDIS Forum, and the CAHPS, HOS & Member Survey Forum. Register for one conference for an in-depth examination of a single area, or design your own event by opting for the all-access pass and choosing the sessions from each conference which correspond exactly to your interests.

More

Upcoming Webinar

Successful and Meaningful Techniques for Integrating Risk and Quality Interventions

Quality measurement and risk adjustment regulations are increasing and the financial impact upon health plans is progressively driving accountability and influencing profitability through payments, penalties, and bonuses. To improve performance and optimize risk and quality payments, Health Plans need to streamline processes, employ best practices for data capture, and focus on strategic interventions that use a member-centric approach.  

Connect With Us

Copyright © 2014 Resource Initiative & Society for Education. All rights reserved.