Is There a Benchmark for HCC Prevalence in Medicare Advantage?

I received an inquiry from a Medicare Advantage plan asking if I knew of any resource that would show the prevalence rates of HCC codes among Medicare Advantage populations.  The notion was to obtain something as a benchmark against which a plan could gauge their own prevalence from risk adjustment work for reasonableness. 

Where do you turn to find out such information?  Among others, I automatically think of Richard Lieberman, "the mad scientist".  He has a great background in research and development in the risk adjustment arena.  Here is what the "mad scientist" had to say:

Dear Kevin:


Other than the EDPS database that CMS has, there is no comprehensive source of benchmarks for HCC prevalence.  That said, I also don’t think it is possible to get a single set of HCC-specific prevalence benchmarks that would be remotely usable.  CMS could, at some point, calculate benchmark prevalence for a 1.0 risk score plan (ideally they would produce 1.0-HMO rates, 1.0-PPO rates, etc.).  But such “benchmark” prevalence rates would only be reasonable for a plan with an average 1.0 risk score.  A 1.1 risk score plan would, of course, have different prevalence rates, as would a 0.9 risk score.  Since risk adjustment is a (loose) measure of morbidity and morbidity varies across plans, I don’t see how one gets to an “expected” number of HCCs that can serve as a viable benchmark.


I would recommend to anyone seeking something resembling a benchmark to look at the historical risk score statistics

This is a veritable treasure trove of data- risk scores by county, by plan type, by plan, by PBP, everything!  This is the closest thing to a benchmark, because it tells you the actual morbidity levels for a particular kind of member.  One can even tie risk scores to particular benefit designs using the PBP and the landscape files.  HCC prevalence rates would have to be presented in a similar way and that is not possible given the limitations of available data.




Richard Lieberman

Chief Data Scientist

Office: 720-446-7785 x 102



Log on to Your Rise Account

Forgot your password?
Create an Account

Association Sponsors

Latest Posts

It’s not Obamacare anymore. It’s our national health-care system.

By Drew Altman and Larry Levitt July 29 Drew Altman is president and chief executive of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. Larry Levitt is senior vice president of the Kaiser Foundation. Republicans failed to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act early Friday because of divisions within their own ranks, and because they tried not only to repeal and replace the ACA but also to cut and cap the Medicaid program, generating opposition from many red-state governors and their senators. But most of all, they failed because they built their various plans on the false claim — busted by the Congressional Budget Office — that they could maintain the same coverage levels as the ACA and lower premiums and deductibles, while at the same time slashing about a trillion dollars from Medicaid and ACA subsidies and softening the ACA’s consumer protection regulations. Had they succeeded, they would have won a big short-term victory with their base, which strongly supports repeal, but suffered the consequences in subsequent elections as the same voters lost coverage or were hit with higher premiums and deductibles. ...
Read More

Where to Now? True North Again

By Kevin Mowll, Executive Director of the RISE Association The failure of the Republicans to repeal, replace, or wreck ObamaCare is a wakeup call for everyone, not just Republicans. While the RISE Association steers away from purely political commentary, the lesson of this protracted political mess needs to be called out for the sake of putting our priorities straight around public policy regarding healthcare reform. In the attached Wall Street Journal article, which suggests that bipartisan solutions are the only remaining way forward, the author proffers hope that the blistering truth will be obvious to all the participants in the 7-year-long fracas around repeal and replace. The bloodied players may still brood in frustration that their political wills were not enough to win, but the author wonders if cooler heads will prevail. I, for one, am not so sanguine; yet I can only hope. The lesson I take away from the many years of wrangling is that the ObamaCare political football games demonstrates that political wills are not the way forward. They lose sight of the True North issue at hand. Rather, the failures of both political parties in arriving at a bipartisan solution signals the fact that what is good for America is good healthcare policy, not political prowess over rivals. Governing from the fringe is not sustainable in a democracy. ...
Read More

Upcoming Conference


RISE West 2017 

Featuring three pre-conference workshops, and five tracks covering 20+ in-depth session topics, this event is an extraordinary value-proposition you don’t want to miss. Hear from industry thought leaders, as well as health plan and provider group experts who will share practical insights and updated lessons learned from the trenches on critical topics in risk adjustment, quality improvement, data management, coding compliance & more!


Upcoming Webinar

The Encounter Management Best Practices Playbook

What encounter best practices can managed care plans put into place to help them manage the pace of change in formats, rules and regulations? What do managed care plans have to stop doing if they want to ensure business continuity with their encounter operations in the face of change and bleeding revenue? What can you do to make sure your plan isn’t one of the ones that figured these things out too late? Join us to get answers to these questions and more on September 12th.


Connect With Us

Copyright © 2014 Resource Initiative & Society for Education. All rights reserved.